New Songs For Old
Posted in General on January 11th, 2009My second year of taking part in Swiss Toni’s shufflethon, and I was very much looking forward to finding out what kind of disk the post would bring me. My hopes were very much that it would introduce me to a few new bands that I would want to explore further, and maybe increase my appreciation of some older ones. I am pleased to announce that the compilation received from Bedshaped has done exactly that.
For the information of those unfamiliar, the idea of the shufflethon is that everyone makes a disk, and sends it to the recipient randomly chosen for us by ST. Then when we receive the disk from our selected sender, we pop a review of it onto our own site. It’s that simple.
The disk came wrapped in clear plastic with a note scrawled on the front in felt marker telling me that the track listing would be posted on his site one he knew I had the disk. This was a good thing, as I had opened the envelope with trepidation, trying not to catch a glimpse of what the disk contained, determined to listen to it blind the first time through. In fact, in the end, I had listened three times through by the time I found out the identities of most of the tracks. There were three on there that I already owned, and so recognised straight away, and two more where I quickly identified the band. But the remaining eleven was a bit of a guessing game, and one I enjoyed playing and discovering them slowly.
So, on with the review.
1. Thru the Glass – Thirteen Senses
When this first started I was a bit worried by the slow synth opening, knowing nothing of Bedshaped’s tastes, that this was going to turn out to be a disk of terminally hip tracks that would leave me a bit baffled. Then the guitars kicked in and I instantly decided I was in good hands. A nice indie-ish feel, but not in a “want to be the Libertines” sort of way, and definitely the sort of thing I would usually listen to. I’m not rushing out to buy one of their albums, but I’ll probably be keeping an ear out for their music again in the future.
2. Lisa – Albert Hammond Jr
Apparently Hammond is a member of the Strokes, a band I’ve never really got on all that well with. But I liked this, although in my initial notes I did wonder if it was Snow Patrol. It’s a kind of bouncy number which combines rock guitars with a bit of a ska type beat. Nice.
3. George Lassoes The Moon – Elbow
What with winning the Mercury Prize, Elbow are a band that seem to have risen in prominence in the last year or so, which makes it quite surprising that, to the best of my knowledge, this is the first time I have heard a song by them. My initial reaction was of a heavy Radiohead influence, but in a good way, for once they seemed like a band that could bear the comparison. I am liking this song more with every listen, and I’ve already been out and bought a couple of their early albums which I look forward to exploring.
4. Duchess – Genesis
Once the two minutes or so of ambient music that forms the intro to this one had finished and the vocals kicked in I instantly recognised the artist, and that it was a song from what I’d describe as their middle period, after Phil Collins had taken over the vocals, but before he realised how much money there was to be made from the singles market and watered down their sound to so much commercial pap. Actually I was vaguely aware that I knew the song, but hadn’t heard it for many years. In fact, I actually saw them on the tour that supported Duke, the album this comes from, so I probably saw them doing it live. I think a lot of people either forget or don’t realise how much good music they produced during this period. A nice reminder, and an inclusion I hardily approve of.
5. The English Way – Fightstar
I know next to nothing about Fightstar except that they were formed by a former member of Busted. Which was certainly enough to put me off straight away. But this is actually quite good. Quite a straightforward, commercial sounding rocker, and it doesn’t inspire me to go out and seek any more of their music, but it’s something I wouldn’t baulk at listening to any time it popped up on random play.
6. How We Operate – Gomez
Gomez are a band I always enjoy when I hear one of their songs, and yet strangely I’ve never actually got round to owning any of their stuff. That is a situation I intend to rectify. This song has a bit of a Pearl Jam feel to it,
7. Lazy Gun – Jet
A bit of a stompalong, this begins with a riff that sounds like it belongs on a Gary Glitter record, and with the vocal it sounds a bit like Oasis gave up on their sixties obsession and moved on to the early seventies. It’s okay, certainly listenable, but doesn’t really grab me.
8. Last Flowers – Radiohead
It took me about thirty seconds to recognise this one, and shamefully I have to admit I had to go and look up the title. It’s from the bonus disk from the In Rainbows limited box-set release, but it sounds kind of OK Computer era. Either way, it’s Radiohead, and that’s always a good thing!
9. Love Is the Law – The Seahorses
Second song in a row that I already owned, but I haven’t listened to the Seahorses album in a long time, and I’d forgotten what a good band they were. Kind of sixties psychedelia throwback. Nice choice.
10. You Will Make It – Jem featuring Vusi Mahlasela
On my initial notes I wrote “Very clean sounding voice. Good diction. Shit, I sound like my old vocal coach.” It’s a piano ballad featuring a female vocalist who I’ve not heard of before, and it’s quite pleasant but a bit nicey-nice for my tastes.
11. Decode – Paramore
My initial reaction was that this was one of those Scandanavian or Northern European “operatic metal” bands like Nightwing or Within Temptation. Repeated listens made me think more of My Chemical Romance with a female singer. Either way, it’s okay, but nothing about it really jumps out at me.
12. Inheritance – Talk Talk
I saw Talk Talk back in 1982 at Milton Keynes Bowl at the Six of the Best gig, the gig where the original Peter Gabriel line-up of Genesis got together for a one-off show. They had had their first chart hit at the time and were still trying to be a kind of New Romantic synth-pop band. The lead singer wore an all white suit and within minutes of taking the stage it was covered in stains from the food and drink that they were bombarded with throughout their set. A few years later I felt sorry for them over that, because they were clearly a talented band who were initially shoe-horned by their record company into trying to be something they were not. But shorn of the pressure to have commercial hits, they became a really interesting and quite experimental group, and this song is a perfect example of that. Another excellent inclusion.
13. Magic Door – Portishead
Recognised this one straight away. From the new album. Great album. Great song. Enough said.
14. What Have I Done – DJ Shadow featuring Christine Carter
One of the problems of this shufflethon business is that you feel entrusted with someone else’s musical taste, and you don’t want to let them down. But on my initial notes from the first listen to this song I wrote just two words. “Pretentious wank.” Sadly, my opinion of it hasn’t improved with repeated listens. Sorry, I tried to find something to like in it, I really did, but it just sounds to me like something put together by someone full of their own self-importance and totally up their own arse. I guess you can’t like everything, and one song out of sixteen ain’t bad!
15. It’s All Over – Broken Family Band
Now this is much better. A nice slice of jangly guitar pop, nothing spectacular but it gets you tapping your feet.
16. Epitaph – Leaves
And what a great way to end. If Elbow was the find of the disk for me, then this runs it a very close second. I’ve never even heard of Leaves, but if this is representative of their music I’m going to hear a lot more of them. A dark and brooding number that builds and builds into a magnificent crescendo before dying away again. Fantastic, this one is going to be on my playlist for a long time to come.
So there we go. Thankyou Bedshaped, it’s a disk that I’ve really enjoyed exploring, and with only one song that I didn’t at least enjoy listening to I’m marking it an unqualified success. If I had to give an overall impression, it is of a disk put together by someone not trying to impress me with their musical taste, but trying to enthuse me into joining them in it.
And thanks also to Swiss Toni, I hope you do this again next year, I’m looking forward to it already.









